Thursday, 22 September 2011

Selecting Coaches

The days after a Test series are always difficult ones. There's the postscripts with every expert - including radio jocks who are to cricket as the Liberal party is to quantum physics - trading in on the team's performance. If its been a bad one, they pillory and attack. If its been a good one, they dig for faults then pillory and attack. The restless need for negativity is fed by a perceived view that they public craves bad news stories to discuss over the tea trolley or the frothy pot at lunch time. If that were true, how do you explain the Tassie Princess and the abnormal doting on each occasion she drops an heir for Denmark? Despite the cosmopolitan ethnicity of Australia thanks to immigration since Hitler and Tojo were sent back to the hell they came from, we essentially haven't escaped our ball and chain background.

For me, in that same aftermath, a sense of loss floods in. The days lack a defined task and daily routine of scanning print media over breakfast, hurried housework before play, the seven hours engaged and the writing afterwards. There is always "normal" life to resume but those five days are as good as any addict's smack attack and withdrawal's a bitch.

Lucky then that Australian and English cricket have ways of keeping themselves in the headlines. Tiny Tim Nielsen has gifted us a month of comment on the coaching position thanks to his incredible ability to spit a dummy all the way from the Bay of Bengal to Melbourne's Jollimont St via the Australian media. Within twenty four hours, the contenders have risen like the morning sun, each trying to block the next with their radiance. Trevor Bayliss, Mickey Arthur and Steve Rixon have all raised their hand in Cricket Australia's most advanced classroom. Rixon would seem the favourite on the basis of experience and performance, current placement as Australia's fielding coach and his closeness to the players, especially The Big Dog, Michael Clarke.

Geoff Lawson
While CA looks for a High Performance Manager, its the coaching and selecting roles which have the hottest interest, possibly because they are positions the public understands. The new role of Chief Selector appears the most pivotal and Rod Marsh and Trevor Hohns have both been named in dispatches and have admitted interest. A third high profile candidate, Geoff Lawson abandoned any hint of coyness yesterday and has openly stated he wants the job, an act likely to work against him within the staid, quiet halls of Cricket Australia. All three have much to salivate over. All three are well credentialled. Lawson may be the choice for the times though. He was the NSW Captain who shook the game up in his state, often prepared to do the unusual in order to have success. Declaring behind, closing the innings without batting, opening the bowling with spinners ... he was innovative and aggressive and he retains that high level of confidence in himself. His working relationship with ex team mate Rixon would be strong.

He may be, however, just too strong a personality. Marsh may have the same problem. They are both types who can bulldoze when push comes to shove, especially if the pushing and shoving is in their direction. Therefore, the quiet man with all the success in the former role, Trevor Hohns, may be the best pick. He continued to build Australian teams after Lawrie Sawle's work in the 80's. His public face was always firm, controlled, informed and respected. That respect extended - admittedly through a period of prolonged success - in a direct line through players, officials, the media and fans.

There's another hour of this long post series day filled in.

4 comments:

  1. The concept of a coach for international cricket is an interesting point for discussion. Warne has maintained that at that level there is no need for a coach but I wonder to what extent that is reflective of his disdain for Buchanan.
    Kirsten and Flower have enjoyed success with India and England respectively and it no doubt has something to do with their good relationships with players of different ages and experience. In both cases any player will speak positively umprompted about their coach. Kirsten and Flower appear proficient at 'man management' as no doubt they are unlikely to be working on basic skills and so there must be something they're doing!
    For this reason I think the best coach for Aus is someone that Clarke and co. respect, listen to and get along with. That's it. If you're good enough to be representing Aus then you shouldn't need someone telling you that you're closing off your front leg or dropping your non-bowling arm too quickly. I doubt Kirsten or Flower told Tendulkar or Cook that they could see deficiencies in their techniques.
    I can only assume a coach plays more of a role in planning and, um, I'm not sure what else. The training has changed and the level of professionalism has become such that cricketers live and breath the sport; not needing to work part-time in a bank. Gone is the time of Bob Simpson and the mid to late 80s when Aus had enough of losing and decided to do something about it. Interestingly Steve Waugh said that in the midst of the domination period the intensity actually dropped off in training. Perhaps a coach just ensures complacency has no place in Australian cricket.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Whilst we are being fair ... Warne did comment negatively about having a coach but he was simply repeating - word for word - what Ian Chappell had said about 8 years earlier. Warne's utterance simply proves some people are good at what they do but not at what they say.
    As for coaches helping players with technique, I'm sure John Buchanan did much in that area but usually after his assistants had gather the intel. I suspect the best coaches work on the mental side of the game as being about 60 to 65%. Anyone can tell a group of players to jog around the oval but the coach we need will have them suggesting it and believing it was their idea.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with your assessment on the role of the head coach in the brain games, and experience counts for a lot there. So despite my irreverent, but gentle, stirring of the pot of religious discrimination yesterday, I agree that Rixon should be the favourite.

    As for the Chief Selector, I'll defer to your better judgement.

    Can anyone tell me what a "High Performance Manager" does? What ever that it is, Tim Nielsen is now going to be doing it for the Redbacks, and I notice Bowls Australia has one too (for some reason I have even more trouble imagining what a "High Performance Manager" might do for bowls...). At least I think I am safe to assume that "high performance" is the object of the job title, and not an adjective.

    ReplyDelete
  4. In terms of bowls, the high performance manager is the one who's awake.

    You may defer to my judgment but "better" will require more than a relative assessment.

    ReplyDelete

Comments will appear after moderation.