Thursday, 31 January 2013

Warnie - Who Really Cares?

"Say what?"
Pub talk never changes much. It's always loud. It always takes an aggressive stance on a topic with black and white answers. It's always veiled in the pretence of authenticity and it's always spoken by the guy who can't be argued with.

Which brings us rather nicely to Shane Warne.

His twitter spray, eventually backed up by a longer website spray, is pub talk. His logic is half baked and the complaints he raises are safe ones, having already been canvassed for weeks in the public domain. His slurs are directed at the "outsiders" - another strong trait of pub talk - and his solutions are popularist tripe. Having promised a baked dinner, he's delivered a string bean.

Warne populated his manifesto with his mates and it smacks of as much thought as any of the actions he has taken both since his Test career ended and during. Great blokes all, some with the talent for the suggested roles but half of them wouldn't be interested in the slightest and have no experience for the role other than they once played cricket ... but in Warney World, mates rates win you a role in the administration. Its like choosing my Forester wagon to run at Bathurst solely because its a car and once bested a clapped out EH from the lights Bridge St.

No role for Warnie of course. All glory, no responsibility. Just the way he likes it and exactly the reason he was never a Test skipper.

A key element of his statement is a dissatisfaction with the rotation of players, as though it is something new. Its new to Test cricket this summer - although some form of it has been practised in the past - but its been with ODI cricket in Australian summers for at least ten years. It has few fans and no one would quibble over short comings which include a short changing of punters who put their money down and deserve to see the best team available when they find their seat at 10:30am on a Test match day. The effect on players and team harmony are longer term effects that Warne is in a position to comment on, based on his own playing days. Had he only written this paragraph, the pressure for change would have been enhanced. Had he not called on the players to revolt, taking the matter into their own hands and turning against management, his thoughts might have held gravitas. Instead, his Les Miserable-like call to action was less "Do You Hear The People Sing?" and more "Do You Hear The People Cringe?".

Pub talk.

"Look, a bright shiny thing!"
The little fat kid from St Kilda 2nds may have graduated to Armani suits, Westwood studs, Zegna shoes but he still thinks with the same brain. He thinks quick and is instinctive: the very quality which made him the best bowler of his generation and made him such a fearsome competitor. Unfortunately, those same qualities make him the worst person to comment on meatier issues because what he says today may change by tomorrow. He's always found it very hard to keep up with himself.

Harrods and the French Riviera might be a long way from St Kilda, but Warne has retained a key element of his working class background. When he hurts, someone else has to hurt. Its no coincidence that he has lashed out against Cricket Australia so soon after his suspension in the Big Bash League. In Warney World, he is above such minor things as punishment. His whole life has been shaped around having someone else take the consequences of his action rather than himself ... the kid took my picture ... the cameraman said it ... my mum gave it to me ... its was their idea ... yeah, Warnie. A litany of lies, excuses and justifications worthy of any pub talking champion.

Smarting from failing to best Marlon Samuels, it got worse when he was suspended and worse still when he was caught handing the captaincy to someone else so he wouldn't be further done for over rates. Smarting really stung when his franchise failed to win for a second successive year.

As anyone who has observed the pub talker get bested at the bar, you know that an awkward, illogical strike back is not far away. Its why punch ups start. When words fail, fists do the business.

This week, Warnie tweeted a swing at Cricket Australia and then, bluff called, provided what has optimistically been called "his plan". Part One has been tabled. Part Two will be his teams and vision. I'm whetting my lips in anticipation of the latter.

John Sutherland, CEO of Cricket Australia, has been polite and assured Warne that an approach is not necessary. As an esteemed former player, there is an open invitation for him to sit down and talk through the issues. Implied, of course, is the rhetorical question as to why Warne hasn't done this ... the clear answer being that it wouldn't provide enough celebrity impact. Warne always has been, after all, as much about style as substance. These days, with dwindling inputs on the field, style has become the more dominant feature to his character.

He assures us, he'll get back to Sutherland when he gets a chance ... sometime ... maybe in the next few days.

Warne plays the local St Kilda boy done good so well that the blokes at the bar just want to be him. They don't care about the things he's done that are outside their code, they just want to be him. If Jay Gatsby represented the American Dream, Warnie is the Aussie version. Who doesn't have a few schooners at the pub and dream of having having a gorgeous bird on the arm of their great bag of fruit and walking up the red carpet at the Border Medal, a household name?

Of course, his instinctive, in the moment thinking gets shown up to be the failure it really is when you look at the facts.

Since the shame of being beaten at home by England, the elevation of Michael Clarke to the captaincy and the Argus Review, the facts are a little different than Warne has painted them.

In all forms, the record since 8th January, 2011, is as follows.



Scroll for ODI and T20 stats.

Roadie?
Warne's cry for change "The current set up is not working, as the results are showing!   What are our world rankings in all forms?" is a little hard to sustain. If Test cricket is the pre-eminent form of the game that everyone except certain Indian businessmen say it is, then a lift from No 5 to No 3 is a fair effort in two years, especially as England sit only one point away at No 2. The ODI ranking was made worse by one series (the disastrous trip to England mid last year) and who really cares what the T20 rating is? Its a game designed for franchises, not international sides.

Much of the rest of Warne's rant on his website are emotion charged claims ... "we'll be where we were 30 years ago" ... designed to have his listeners jump to attention. This morning on social media, there were plenty who were calling on him to be made the next Prime Minister in that way that only the blissfully ignorant can do when they are looking over the froth. His disclaimer ... "I may be completely wrong and barking up the wrong tree" ... is the final piece of classic pub talk and just watch them all come in spinner.

For the record, 30 years ago we'd just beaten England 2-1 at home, with Kim Hughes, Greg Chappell, Hookes, Wessells and Border staring with the bat and Lawson (34), Thommo and Roo Yardley (22 a piece) running through the Poms in Brisbane and Adelaide. No, we wouldn't want to go back there!

Warnie leaves us with his real intention, to stir and goad and create talk in all of the best of uninformed places. It will no doubt work. It always has at the St Kilda Arms.

Best dismiss Lizzy's Squeeze with an English expression, mainly because he'd hate it. Tosser or pratt? You take you pick.

Meanwhile, the rest of us will get on with getting the job done.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments will appear after moderation.