With the Ashes about to start, its time for thecricketragics to dust of the exposed can pads, oil the Duncan Fearnley and pull on the green pimples and face up to the season again.Let's start with Ian Chappell.
Chappelli - not bloody Chapps - was not one of Australia's greatest batsmen. He was in the very bloody good class which sits at a ever so slightly lower level. He was, however, one of Australia best captains, learning lessons before he took on the job from Richie Benaud and even more potent ones from the moment he got the job. He was acerbic, brash, confident and led a group of men from rabble to one of the best oiled and organised teams ever to wear the Baggy Green. From his captaincy came two greats - Greg Chappell, Dennis Lillee - and another four you like him were in the very, very good class - Jeff Thompson, Rod Marsh, Doug Walters, Max Walker. Even the "others" like Ross Edwards, Gary Gilmour, Ashley Mallett, were damn fine cricketers. Chappelli made them into a team. It was a place where egos were built up and knocked down. It was not a place for self.
thecricketragics have long been a fan of Chappelli. We watched him play. We saw him fight. He would turn up the collar, glance up toward the light to adjust his vision, take guard, adjust his box ... and then spit in the eye of the best fast bowlers in the world. He was the batsman of my generation who you would have bat for your life and still enjoy the ride. Boycott was safer, would make sure you didn't die , but who wants to live on life support.
As a commentator and journalist - again following Richie - he has been just as forthright. He gives you as much to agree with as disagree. His opinion pieces create comment; invite argument. In the main, I find myself agreeing with him a lot of the time but engaging with him always.
His latest piece, Chappells Top 25 Ashes Performers, fittingly placed as kindling in a place to burn the house down, can't go without comment for it is flawed. He has give himself the excuse of picking his twenty five on the basis of his "eye", not stats. However, if these are the top 25 Ashes performers, then their performances have to be considered. Further, accusations that might keep a player from inclusion, have to be proven.
Let's turn to the chief comment that has been drawn from the article, namely that Steve Waugh was left out because he was a "selfish" cricketer. It really is hard to justify this accusation. Its been made before and parroted by his blonder, less less journalistically credentialled mouthpiece Warne often enough. In Warne's case, being dropped by Waugh and the tour selectors in the West Indies in 1999 when he had taken 2/268 in three Tests has never been forgiven. What is always overlooked is it was Waugh's first series as skipper. Takes some balls. Chappell has just never understood Waugh. Waugh is all the cricketers Chappell disliked. He thought him cold and calculating. He judged him risk averse as a captain and in these opinions, he's probably right, but selfish? Chappell claims the manner in which Waugh rotated the strike with tailenders instead of shielding them was an example of his selfishness. Batting for red ink he has often claimed. Waugh has always claimed that it was placing enhanced expectations on his tail: making them realise they are part of the batting unit, needed to train and needed to take on a role. Propped up on their bat at the bowlers end disengaged them from the game and led to more needless dismissals such as run outs caused by a lack of experience of batting like a batsman. thecricketragics have read statistical summaries that may prove this to have been an important innovation.
That aside, how Chappell can exclude a man with more than 3000 Ashes runs at 58, who captained his team to 8 Ashes victories from 9 Tests and who three times was man of the match in an Ashes test, is hard to explain other than another stone thrown across the road at a disliked neighbour. If Waugh is not in the top three Ashes performers since 1972, then I've been watching baseball.
Waugh is not the only exclusion.
![]() |
| Where is Clem? |
Of those included, some big question marks. Three keepers? Really? Rodney Marsh - as noted - was very, very good but not in the class of Knotty and Heals. Yes to them, no to Baccus.
Mark Waugh? Absolutely. Look at his performances in Ashes matches. They were stunning.
Graeme Swann was effective for England in every other event other than Ashes Tests matches, where he was a consistent failure. Ben Stokes certainly looks like he will be a force to come but as yet, his performances don't give him a deserved place among the top 25. Sure, he came out swinging in Perth last time but we realise now, that was less form and more lifestyle choice. Even my beloved Doug Walters place in Chappell's list has to be questions. He was devastating in Australia but was eventually dropped in his last campaign in England because of his inability to curb his slanted backlift and wafting outside off stump.
Even if you accept all of the inclusions, the ordering is interesting. The top five are pretty much right but Allan Border at 24?
Its okay to say "this is my opinion" and "statistics don't count" in your selection but if you are picking the best performers, they have to have performed well and often.
Some of these haven't, not in Ashes cricket at least and that was the criteria.


No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments will appear after moderation.